Friday, February 17, 2012


            When I read that I would need to select one passage to write about for this blog post I immediately knew which one I would choose. I chose the last line of the story, “Ah Bartleby! Ah humanity!” This simple four word line brings together all the emotion from the story for the final conclusion. As I was reading “Bartleby, The Scrivener A Story of Wall Street” I felt an amazing amount of frustration at the situation Herman Melville found himself in with Bartleby. At reading the conclusion of the story it was like all that emotion was released and it really felt as if the story was resolved.
            Now, to look at the language, there isn’t much to look at but there is much to say. The word “humanity” sums up the whole meaning of the story. Bartleby’s behavior was certain odd and it was his odd behavior that kept me reading but what was more important about the story was how Melville reacted to his behavior. He was kind and submissive to Bartleby at times even though his behavior was far from normal. Melville had patience and compassion, qualities that I’m not sure any man on Wall Street has today. If a man was to behave this way on Wall Street today he would be arrested immediately and no one would care what happened to him. People would just see him as some crazy loon who decided to squat in a Wall Street office (if he could even gain access to such an office). Today we focus too much on material things and very few of us would show the compassion that Melville did to Bartleby. He tried everything he could think of to help him out. He even went so far as to invite Bartleby, the man who would reveal nothing about himself, to live with him in his own home. But nothing he did was going to change the outcome of the situation. In the end there was nothing else that could be done because there was obviously something wrong with Bartleby and in the end he starved himself to death. Ah the humanity! 


5 comments:

  1. Molly,
    I like that you chose to focus on humanity. Your focus on Melville and his reaction to Bartleby was interesting to me as well. I think you are right there are few on wall street that would care much now. Our society is so focused on material things that we rarley care about the person next door. You are right Melville does get a great deal of persecution in the situation and yet he is the one who offers to let Bartleby live in his house.I did have to ask myself was Melville really kind and submissive? Was Melville so shocked by having something so out of the ordinary, he didn't know how to react. This was a very thought provoking story. Thanks for your insight.
    Carli

    ReplyDelete
  2. Molly,
    I agree that humanity was a central idea in the story. Although the narrator did show compassion for Bartleby, in the end, he chose to abandon him. He valued his colleague’s opinions more than helping Bartleby. One might argue that the narrator has done everything he can. However, if he had dug deeper and found what really made Bartleby give up on life, he may have been able to inspire him. It is interesting that you mention material values because the narrator states that humoring Bartleby would have cost him little of nothing. As far as the outcome goes, I believe the relocation is the straw that broke the camel's back. At this point, the narrator has given up and when he finds out that Bartleby has starved, he seems to second guess his actions. Good Post.
    -Aaron Isaacson

    ReplyDelete
  3. I disagree with you about him abandoning Bartleby. Yes he did choose to move his office because of his work colleagues but he really had no other choice. He did EVERYTHING he could in the end to help the man that wouldn't be helped.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Molly,
    Thank you for your insight on the story of Bartleby. Melville, his boss, did try everything he could but became exasperated with the situation he found himself in several times. You picked the end of the story as I did, that last line does sum it up quite well. Melville did have genuine concern for Bartleby. I believe that Melville really wanted to see a different outcome for Bartleby; however you cannot help someone who does not want to help themselves. The story of Bartleby, the scrivener made me look at my "independent" self and wonder how many times was there an offer of help for me and I refused. I guess I need to be more in tune with those who really see a need in me and want to help. Very good job on your post, I wish you the best in Eng 102.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Molly,
    Your interpretation on the story of Bartleby helped me actually understand it better after already reading the story myself. Focusing on humanity made your post very clear about what you talked about. I agree with you that people on Wall Street today act nowhere near as passionate about their workers as Melville did towards Bartleby, even though he gave nothing in return to Melville. I believe that he saw what he thought Bartleby could eventually become because of his work ethic in the beginning of the story, but then Bartleby began to act odd, and Melville wanted nothing but the best for him. Great post!
    -Taylor Ivie

    ReplyDelete